Click Fraud
Sep
20
2012
PON (EPON/GPON) versus Point to Point Ethernet

Unlike the DSL, which uses existing copper infrastructure of telephony and cable operators, the FTTx network requires new installation. There might be two scenarios: greenfield – when the cables are wired together with other cables in new build houses or office building or brownfield – when the existing cable ducts are modified.
Two most expanded types of the FTTx networks are PON and P2P Ethernet. PON is a passive type point-to-multipoint network having active points on the ends and passive equipment (splitters, fibers, etc.) in between. P2P network is using active switches instead of passive splitters.

 

PON_versus_Point_to_Point_Ethernet

 

Figure 1. Comparison of two different FTTH technologies. The PON network to the top is having only passive splitters between CO and ONTs. The P2P network to the bottom is having distribution nodes (mostly L2 switches) and access nodes (L2 or L3 equipment) between CO and optical/electrical conversion (in the home).

 

PON is more established in America and Asia, while P2P Ethernet is more popular in Europe. As an example we can take Sweden, where market is dominated by P2P solutions. One of the reasons for that is close collaboration of leading FTTH operator – TeliaSonera, with Ericsson and academia. Therefore the business models are often adapted to fit technology, rather than the other way round.

 

The cost of trenching associated with fibre infrastructure deployment will completely overshadow the access system cost, regardless of the system architecture.

 

Now, for future study, you can take a look at real products used in one or another strategy.

 

GEPON (EPON range) from AD-net

 

and

 

PTP Ethernet solutions, mostly Fiber Optical Media converters

Testimonials

Lomoveishiy – Finland

I needed those to connect my PC on the third floor to have internet access in that room, and ISP installed their modem on the first floor only. After dropping fiber patch cables, plugged in all cables into these media converters at both sides, and link came up instantly. Was much easier than I thought!

Raymond – USA

Great experience – units worked straight out of the box – just needed plug in cables and we were done. I also like the possibility to enable jumbo frames, while we do not have a need for this feature at the current moment it’s great to have this option.

Stay in touch via e-mail newsletter!

Subscribe to our mailing list for weekly performance tips

[recaptcha]